Testing Rubric Discussion

This will be an open discussion about the testing rubric CNA will be using. Post any thoughts you have.

My idea is to make it out of 100 points and look something like this:


Skill:#/35 (35 points win or 0 points lose)

Rulings:#/20(Knowledge of rulings)

Speed:#/10(If they move slowly they will lose a few points)


Build: #/30(how well their deck is built i.e. too many cards, random cards(there is a difference between random cards and tech cards)

Deck: #/5(They will lose either have the full five points of 0 points. They will receive 0 points if they use a Ftk/Otk deck or a Tier 1/Meta Deck. Decks that POTENTIALLY Otk are fine but if they are based around Otk/Ftk in a wierd manner other than battle, they shall receive 0 points)

What are your thoughts?

how about this

Tester deck/dn name: (ex: slicex2xkill tigerless gladiator beast)
Testee deck/dn name: (ex:busterking machina gadgets)

tier -/5 ( lower tier high + )
card usage -/5
side deck/extra -/5
attitude -/10
ruling -/10
testers opinion -/10
control of the duel -/15
concentration -/20
win/loss 20 total +10 ea win

testers helpful tips? ( explain what they need to work on )

-/100

welcome to slifer red 65/100

welcome to ra yellow 75/100

welcome to  obelisk blue 85/100

welcome to dominant dark dorm 95/100

What if they score under 60?

well obviously its red then but i made it easy.
i think its easy to get atleast 40 points concentration and win the match is automatic 40 the rest depends on playing skills as well as personality n deck

im good with this

Approved until further notice this will be our testing rubric. This discussion will remain open to discuss flaws with it or changes ~BusterKing

Should there be monthly tests, or just welcome tests?

Probably just welcome tests. People can retest but they will have to pay crimson points. If a user leaves leaves for a while and comes back then they will need a retest.

How do 'crimson points' work

Basically, if you win a shadow duel or a tournament you get points but I'll take points for name color change etc. think of it like a system of money.

and u start off broke

Well thats waht deck shops and wager dues are for XD

So when is a tourney starting?

We need to recruit more. I'll actually be on my computer later so I'll recruit and update the chatbox then

Idk why but today i felt really lazy and such but I'll try and recruit but i generaly am at my A-game when no admins are on

How about this?

CNA Username/DN Username/Deck Name for both tester and testee

-/15 (+5 each win)

-/10 (rulings: do they know their rulings)

-/5 (speed: -1 each time they look like they passed out aka 2-3 minutes)

Optional:

-/5 (courtesy: do they wait for you to play veiler or do they go ahead and continue?)

-/5 (politeness: do they say good luck or do they just go ahead and start?)

-/5 (having fun: do they act like they are having fun?)

-/5 (tier: do they play meta decks or do they play weaklings?)

-/50 (total)

Less than or equal to 30 slifer red

31-40 ra yellow

41-47 obelisk blue

48-50 dominant dark

I'll compare it to our current one this weekend

pshhaw aint nobody got time for that

Lol during winter break I might

i agree with like 1 of the few things but i like the one we got better it's preatty easy to learn heck i learnt it after a few tries that's not bad this one confuses alot too many high numbers